[His expression turns mischievous, idly licking his lips as they draw back from the kisses. Tastes like lake.]

That's a rare trait for my catches to have… most of them would rather put up a fight, but you fell right into my arms. What should I do with such an enthusiastic fish?

[This feels a bit like some kind of mermaid fairytale parody. Perhaps she has a water-elemental in there somewhere, too?]